How to Maintain Authenticity in Your Social Media Strategy

In today’s fast-paced digital world, social media is a powerful tool for brands to connect with their audience. But with so much content vying for attention, authenticity has become the key to standing out and building lasting relationships. This post explores how businesses can maintain genuine connections on social platforms while driving engagement and growth.

Why Authenticity Matters More Than Ever

Consumers are increasingly savvy and skeptical of overly polished or insincere content. Being authentic fosters trust, encourages loyalty, and humanizes your brand. Consumers don’t connect with brands, they connect with the people behind the brands. When your audience feels you’re genuine, they’re more likely to engage, share, and become advocates.

Insights show, brands that prioritize authenticity see higher engagement rates and stronger customer retention. This is especially true on platforms like Instagram, TikTok, and LinkedIn, where personal stories and transparent communication resonate deeply. 86% of consumers prioritize authenticity when deciding which brand they purchase from, while 81% need to trust a brand before purchasing. Trust is the keyword here. Brands who are authentic build stronger trust and will build strong relationships with consumers. 

1. Craft a Consistent Brand Voice That Reflects Your Values

Authenticity starts with a clear, consistent brand voice that aligns with your company’s core values. Is your tone is friendly? professional? or playful? Either one, it should feel natural, relatable to your audience, and stay consistent across all social channels.

To develop this voice, involve your team in a brainstorming jam session to define what your brand stands for and how you want to communicate. If you’re a solo-entrepreneur use ChatGPT to get the wheels spinning or to refine a draft you’ve already started. Make sure to give ChatGPT as much context on your industry, brand, and target audience as possible to improve its response. Avoid jargon or buzzwords that don’t add real meaning. Instead, focus on storytelling that highlights your mission, culture, and the people behind your brand.

Actionable tip: Once you’ve established a direction create a brand voice guide that can be referenced at anytime and share it with everyone who manages your online content to ensure consistency across platforms and marketing materials. 

2. Share Real Stories and Behind-the-Scenes Content

Audiences crave transparency. Sharing behind-the-scenes glimpses of your team, processes, wins/loses, company culture, and even live thoughts, helps humanize your brand and build emotional connections. Real stories about challenges, successes, and everyday moments make your content relatable and trustworthy.

For example, HubSpot’s social team grew their LinkedIn presence by showcasing authentic employee stories and candid moments, which boosted engagement by 84%. This approach invites your audience into your world rather than just broadcasting polished marketing messages that get drowned out by all the other brands creating authentic content. 

Actionable tip: Use Instagram Stories/Reels, TikTok, or LinkedIn posts to highlight your team’s day-to-day activities or customer success stories.

3. Engage Authentically with Your Community

Authenticity is a two-way street. Engaging with your audience by responding to comments, asking questions, and participating in conversations shows that you value their input. Avoid generic replies; instead, personalize your interactions to build genuine relationships. This is a big one our team truly believes in and if you want to take it up a notch, follow ALL your leads and past customers on social media to stay engaged with their content updates. We share more insight on why this is powerful on this instagram post. 

Additionally, user-generated content (UGC) is a powerful way to showcase real customer experiences. Sharing UGC not only provides social proof but also demonstrates that you listen and appreciate your community.

Actionable tip: Set aside time daily (doesn’t have to be long) to respond thoughtfully to comments and messages, and encourage followers to share their stories using branded hashtags. Your goal should be to build rapport with your audience through your content and engagement. Be responsive, be friendly, be grateful they are engaging with you, be genuine! 

4. Balance Promotional Content with Value-Driven Posts

While promoting your products or services is important, too much sales-focused content can feel pushy and erode trust. Instead, balance promotional posts with educational, inspirational, or entertaining content that provides real value to your audience.

For example, our mission for our blog is to offer a wealth of resources that brands can use as guides to make better marketing decisions. Whether its creating content that educates and empowers their audience or providing them with the knowledge to enhance marketing campaigns, our content (and yours) should balance value and promotion strategically. This approach will position your brand as a helpful resource rather than just a vendor.

Actionable tip: A good rule to follow is the 80/20 rule—80% value-driven content, 20% promotional—to keep your social media authentic and engaging.

Conclusion: Build Trust by Being Real

Authenticity is no longer optional in social media marketing—it’s essential. By crafting a consistent brand voice, sharing real stories, engaging genuinely, and balancing your content thoughtfully, you can build trust and foster meaningful connections with your audience.

Ready to take your social media strategy to the next level?

Looking for more valuable content like this? Then you’ll love the next blog “How to Connect Authentically with Diverse Audiences“

J. Oliver Advertising
Instagram
5 Star Reviews